Wireless Summit II

Earlier this month, I met with 25 other contributors at the 2nd Linux Wireless Summit. This was a followup from the 2006 summit.

The meeting happened in London and was scheduled to occur immediately after the IEEE 802.11 working group meeting. This enabled us to get some kind of vendor attendance.

While we had this opportunity, one of the biggest topics was discussion of why vendors still aren’t playing nice in releasing open source drivers (or providing the resources to let the community do so). The vendors in the room confirmed our suspicions – vendors are afraid of the FCC and other regulatory agencies who place restrictions on frequencies and power levels which these devices are legally allowed to transmit as.

Matt Norwood from the Software Freedom Law Center was in attendance and had studied the FCC regulations in some detail. The conclusion is that the FCC rules are vague and while they don’t explicitly say that open source drivers are not allowed, vendors are not prepared to risk falling out of compliance and are playing it safe (or not playing at all). Unfortunately there is no short term solution to this: it would take years for the FCC to clarify the regulations. Short term workarounds such as finding ways to encourage vendors to produce open drivers with only the regulatory part closed (such as Intel’s ipw3945 offering) are under investigation.

The other large topic was the merge of the new wireless stack (d80211) which was donated to the community by Devicescape. The stack has many more features than the current in-kernel ieee80211/softmac stack, and improves consistency between drivers. We are now much closer to getting d80211 merged into mainline Linux, but there are still some significant technical issues to be resolved.

Before the conference, several people asked me if I could raise issues with the suckiness of Intel’s ipw3945 driver offering in that it relies on this awkward closed-source userspace daemon. Fortunately Intel have found a way to rewrite their firmware so that the regulatory domain control is no longer at the driver level, therefore a fully open-source driver with no binary userspace part has been developed (iwlwifi). Although Intel have not yet announced it, the source code has been released here. This rewritten driver uses the d80211 stack mentioned above, so it’s not possible just to compile it against mainline Linux at the moment. The iwlwifi website includes instructions for how to check out the wireless-dev tree where d80211 is being held.

All slides and notes from the conference can be found here. Stephen Hemminger wrote a more detailed summary. Also, one other significant product of the summit was a central information source aimed at Linux wireless users – we have now launched linuxwireless.org.

4 Responses to “Wireless Summit II”

  1. Martin Garton Says:

    This is a very informative post. IMO It’s often hard for people to see what’s going on with linux wireless, and this sort of information helps a lot. Thanks Daniel.

  2. Peper IT » Blog Archive » WiFi ondersteuning in Linux sterk verbeterd Says:

    [...] Een van de problemen waar vooral veel beginnende Linux-gebruikers mee geconfronteerd worden, is vaak het aan de praat krijgen van hun draadloze (WiFi) netwerk. Ontwikkelaars zijn echter van plan om dit probleem op korte termijn aan te gaan pakken. Op de Linux Wireless Summit die vorige maand plaatsvond in London, was de situatie al besproken. Kernelontwikkelaars zaten er om de tafel met vertegenwoordigers van Intel, Broadcom, Devicescape, MontaVitsa en Nokia en de bijeenkomst was volgens Linux-ontwikkelaar Stephen Hemminger ontzettend productief. [...]

  3. Momsen Reincke Says:

    On Feb 9th Intel announced the iwlwifi somehow officially on intelwireless.org (well, it’s still experimental nevertheless). I tried it and it basically works, although some people are experiencing problems…

  4. Linux Wireless Summit II « /home/liquidat Says:

    [...] really got around about that. Anyway, Stephen Hemminger and Daniel Drake have two detailed summaries of the [...]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.